[Web4lib] The P-Word II > The Ontology of Plagiarism: Part Two > Get A Clue

[gerrymck]

Colleagues/

In response to his recent NY Times Opinionator Piece > Plagiarism Is Not A
Big Moral Deal

[
http://scholarship20.blogspot.com/2010/08/p-word-stanley-fish-and-i-agree.html
]
,

Stanley Fish has authored "The Ontology of Plagiarism: Part Two "

[snip]

IMHO > Most Still Do Not (Really) Recognize/Understand The Issue(s) > Please
(Do) View / Read My Perspective On The Issue >>>

A few years ago I gave a keynote at the 3rd International Plagiarism
Conference / 23 - 25 June 2008 / City Campus East, Northumbria University /
Newcastle-upon-tyne, UK /

"Disruptive Scholarship: An Idea Whose Time Has Come: (Re)Use / (Re)Mix /
(Re)New"

Abstract

Hadrian's Wall is a stone and turf fortification built by the Roman Empire
across the width of modern-day England. ... [It was] 117 kilometres long,

... [I]ts width and height [were] dependent on the construction materials
[that] ... were available nearby.

... [T]he wall in the east follow[ed] the outcrop of a hard, resistant
igneous diabase rock escarpment ... Local limestone was used in the
construction, except for ... section[s] in the west ... where turf was used
instead ... .

The Broad Wall was initially built with a clay-bonded rubble core and
mortared dressed rubble facing stones, but this seems to have made it
vulnerable to collapse, and repair with a mortared core was sometimes
necessary.... [I]n time ... [Hadrian's] Wall was abandoned and fell into
ruin. Over the centuries and even into the twentieth century a large
proportion of the stone was reused in other local buildings.

Throughout history, humans have (re)used local resources to create not only
buildings and fortifications, but monuments, roads, and a wide variety of
other structures. For countless generations, artists, composers, and writers
have freely incorporated elements from local and distant cultures to create
new visual, musical, and textual forms.

In The Web 2.0 World, the open (re)combination of multiple media has become
commonplace in many venues, practices that Lawrence Lessig [snip], founder
of Creative Commons [snip]and others, would characterize as emblematic of a
'Remix ' or 'Read/Write' culture. Indeed, from his point of view, “the
health, progress, and wealth creation of a culture is fundamentally tied to
this participatory remix process” [snip]

In the recently-released Horizon Report 2008 - a joint publication of the
New Media Consortium (NMC) and the EDUCAUSE Learning Initiative (ELI), six
emerging information technologies and practices that are expected to
significantly impact educational organizations are profiled: Grassroots
Video, Collaborative Webs, Mobile Broadband, Data Mashups, Collaborative
Intelligence, and Social Operating Systems.

In this presentation, we will review the Read/Write Traditions of the Arts,
Humanities, and Sciences; analyze key Past / Present / Future Participatory
Technologies; and explore the potential of Web 2.0 for creating/fostering
Disruptive Learning / Scholarship / Teaching in the 21st century.

The Director's Cut of the (150+ Slides) PPT is available from my
_Scholarship 2.0_ blog at

[ http://bit.ly/9riXmc ]

I hope The Title and Abstract indicate That I Have A Different View Of The
P-Word [:-)]

/Gerry

Gerry McKiernan
Associate Professor
Science and Technology Librarian
Iowa State University Library
Ames IA 50011

Follow Me On Twitter > http://twitter.com/GMcKBlogs

"It's Not About Publication; It's About Ideas"

[ http://bit.ly/bb6uW7 ]