[WEB4LIB] Re: Collegiality is unchanged; ditto the reference
interview
Frank Bridge
bridgef at co.chesterfield.va.us
Mon Oct 21 10:54:10 EDT 2002
I cannot speak for Mr. Drew. However, my response remains completely
unchanged. I did not understand the scope of the student's question,
and would have asked for clarification as part of a standard reference
interview. This portion of my response would have been unchanged
whether or not I had known that the asker was a student.
However, once knowing that the person was a student, I would have
attempted to determine whether, through my response to the reference
question, I was interfering with the purpose of the assignment. It
would not be the first time that a student has asked me a reference
question that the student was supposed to answer fully him/herself as
part of the assignment.
You also posed the question, "...What if you, as a digital resource, are
part of the research?" That question is a good example of what I would
try to untangle as part of answering the student's inquiry. I also
believe that the student has some responsibility for explaining this to
me at the start of the exchange. I am doing that student a disservice
by knowingly or unknowingly performing his/her work.
And I could not determine whether this actually was the student's work,
based upon the original question as framed by the student.
"Joyce M. Latham" wrote:
>
> But what if you, as a digital resource, are part of the research? As I
> pointed out to Mr. Drew, we often seek clarification of those posing
> questions about the scope of their project. If he had not identified
> himself as a student, what would the response have been?
>
> Joyce Latham
> GSLIS -- UofI
>
> Frank Bridge wrote:
> >
> > I saw the student's posting in the same way as Mr. Drew--it was
> > difficult to determine what the student wanted. His posting suffered
> > from the same problem as any other reference question we receive daily
> > on the floors of our libraries--determining the exact nature of the
> > inquiry, and the lengths to which the answerer is expected to go in
> > order to provide a satisfactory response.
> >
> > This is particularly interesting to untangle when the asker is a student
> > who is expected to gain educational experience from performing the
> > research and completing the assignment himself.
> >
> > "Joyce M. Latham" wrote:
> > >
> > > My students are also doing a Web4Lib assignment ... although you may not
> > > be aware of them. They have been monitoring the contents of the site
> > > all semester, and we discuss what topics emerge on the list every
> > > Friday. I have also occasionally encouraged students to post a query to
> > > the list ... usually because I don't know the answer to the question.
> > >
> > > The point is to investigate what avenues are available to assist with
> > > the diffusion of IT knowledge. I don't know about anyone else, but when
> > > I got started with IT in libraries the collegiality within the
> > > profession was critical to the successful (most of the time) adoption of
> > > technology -- especially in my libraries. I was often just a step or
> > > two ahead of everyone else in the library, so got the IT management
> > > job. It was challenging -- and often scary. We needed to help each
> > > other.
> > >
> > > While I was in NC, we started a microcomputers users group
> > > for libraries that sponsored a computer camp for librarians every summer
> > > -- ran for a week and cost $100. You could learn how to take a pc apart
> > > and put it back together, or you could learn dBASE III+, or Lotus ...
> > > those of us who knew something, sponsored a track ... those of us who
> > > didn't, took the classes in the track ... too bad we've commercialized
> > > so much of what we know ...
> > >
> > > We cared about enabling our colleagues ... I hope we still do. As far
> > > as I'm concerned, my students -- any students -- are as much my
> > > colleagues as any practicing librarian who already knows it all and
> > > doesn't need any help. We have an opportunity here to continue the
> > > supportive environment that can promote best practice and network the
> > > lonely techies out there in libraries all over the country ...
> > >
> > > Joyce Latham
> > > Graduate School of Library and Information Science
> > > University of Illinois
> > >
> > > "Drew, Bill" wrote:
> > > >
> > > > Are we now doing homework for LIS students? What does "Bill" want from us?
> > > >
> > > > Bill Drew
> > >
> > > --
> > > Joyce M. Latham
> > > GSLIS -- University of Illinois
> >
> > --
> > Frank R. Bridge,
> > Technology Management Administrator
> > Chesterfield County Public Library
> > 9501 Lori Rd.
> > PO Box 297
> > Chesterfield, VA 23832-0297
> > Voice: 804-748-1980
> > Fax: 804-751-4679
>
> --
> Joyce M. Latham
> GSLIS -- University of Illinois
--
Frank R. Bridge,
Technology Management Administrator
Chesterfield County Public Library
9501 Lori Rd.
PO Box 297
Chesterfield, VA 23832-0297
Voice: 804-748-1980
Fax: 804-751-4679
More information about the Web4lib
mailing list